Is Private Property Biblical? Christianity, Wealth, Socialism & Stewardship

Cameron (00:01.099)

you're so fortunate to be here because this is thinking out loud. And I'm your co host, Cameron McAllister.

Nathan (00:06.679)

that is such a new introduction, and I'm your co host, Nathan Rittenhouse.

Cameron (00:09.88)

Well, Nathan's been around the world, he's been out and about, he got caught in that FAA standstill fiasco, and he's okay. So he survived it. There's some yeah, he's got some bags under his eyes. That's okay. But you were on assignment in Hawaii, suffering for the kingdom in Hawaii as as you were.

Nathan (00:18.64)

yes. I survived it.

Nathan (00:33.708)

Hanging out down there with the youngins at Wy Wam.

Cameron (00:36.834)

Yes, and there's been something on your mind lately, Nathan, and I know that you got some insightful questions while you were there. One of those insightful questions had to do with ownership and property and human rights. As anytime the word rights comes up, human rights or rights language, Nathan Nathan gets into a certain sort of mood. So I'm wondering why why did this get you Yeah, this really got you thinking.

Nathan (00:53.396)

Relaxa

Cameron (01:07.002)

So clue us in a little bit, Nathan.

Nathan (01:08.012)

No, w well well, I appreciate it. Yeah. And I think people are always curious about what are the changing nature of of the questions and what's being said, what's being asked. and a lot of them were very standard, apologetically Christian circle ones. Couple about psilocybin and drugs and spiritual experiences that I think are indicative of the time and seeing a a trend in that direction to that being a more of an open open conversation. I mean, of course, lots of good things to say there from a Christian perspective. So that was there.

and then somebody was just kind of saying asking me, like, what about ownership? What is a biblical or or Christian perspective on ownership? And I think I think for many generations, particularly in the American context, a lot of Christians haven't had to think deeply about that. I think if you look at a rise of conversations about socialism, I think if you look at rising housing cost, a lot of young people are there's there's just a everything is is up in the air. And so this is a very good question. It's a very honest question. And I think

is that's one that's worth us working through together when it comes to kind of what what is a biblical perspective of ownership. so we can let's let's start broadly. Yeah, let me kind of give you a a a broad direction of where I went with an answer to this and how I've been thinking about this in the last couple years. And then yeah we we can we can expand out from there. So let me put my bottom line up front that I I think what I read between the lines

in scripture is and that we can best use in our modern Christian thinking on this is I'm going to use the phrase designated stewardship. Designated stewardship. And so what what this is saying is that you know like I was I was thinking of a f a funny example a couple of years ago our our daughter was like you know fighting with the brothers and yeah I don't want them coming into my room. And I say hang on a second, whose room is it? And they say, well, you know, she said it's not really my room. It's in

our house. And I'm yeah, and we rent this house. And she's yeah, so actually it'd be named our landlords. And then you just kind of go up through it of the definition of my and mind is usually stacked within some sort of broader framework. and then obviously if we're looking at this as Christians or biblically speaking, we're going to say the earth is the Lord's and everything in it. You look at Colossians one about all things being created by for and through Christ. And so we have this kind of majestic vision of whose it all is, whose is all of this stuff.

Cameron (03:10.412)

Mm-hmm.

Cameron (03:33.21)

Mm-hmm.

Nathan (03:34.666)

And then we're called to use it and to kind of draw lines on maps and draw draw boundaries around what does it mean to say, this is my pen, this is my laptop, this is my house. Where do we go from this? and and how do we work that out? And so yeah, I think in a time in which the younger crew flirting with concepts from communism to socialism and on out from there, yeah, it's a good time to have this conversation. So

Let me lay out quickly my definition of designated stewardship, and then you push back a little bit, Cameron, and then we'll we'll un unfold into the details from there. But I think designated stewardship, I'm drawing this mainly from Jesus' parables, which I know exegetically can be a trick, but but in the parables, what's being talked about is you have so many of them that are a master going on a journey and leaving people in charge of things.

leaving people behind and saying, look, I I'm putting you in charge of this thing. I want you to take care of this spot. And so the the person left in charge recognizes that the thing is not theirs and rightfully stewarded, develops, increases, makes it better, but is accountable to the master for the way in which they use the thing that had been entrusted to them. Now, this is funny to think about when you think about the fact that most of the things that those of you who are listening, the things that you have, you paid for.

So you would say nobody is entrusting this thing to me. I had to work to earn income in order to spend that equity, you know, that's spend my blood, sweat, and tears in order to have this thing. But there really is no situation in which it can be said that you have it. I mean, say you have a house, unless you don't pay the taxes, or unless all of your neighbors ganged up and have bigger guns than you and can take it. And so there's a sense in which there is no real permanence to having.

under any structure. Now certainly certain societal and legal structures and cultures are way better at maintaining order in this category. And I'm thankful to live in one of those. But at the end of the day, if you're thinking about this theologically, it isn't yours. It is a responsibility that you have been entrusted with to use well. And that sets some boundaries there because let's say Cameron that you have let's say you have a mug in your cupboard that is yours.

Nathan (05:57.59)

And the and your household acknowledges that it is yours. That means that you get to say something about I don't want my kids making mud pies in it. I don't want watercolor paint in it. I don't want it to be used as a baseball. you can you can set some parameters around the way that you want it. And those could be done out of just your personal preference, or you could have a higher vision of like this is the thing that I use to drink coffee of, and I've set it apart for this strategic use. And therefore, since it is mine and I have a vision for how it should be used.

Then I can draw some boundaries on what other people aren't allowed to do with it. Most of the time, I think when we think of property rights or boundaries or you know, a car title, you're saying this thing is mine and therefore nobody else is allowed to use it. And therefore, the the ownership language is a restriction of saying what other people can't do with it. What I like about the concept of designated stewardship is to say, okay, this is a thing that has been entrusted to my care.

Cameron (06:46.542)

Mm-hmm.

Nathan (06:55.115)

And I am to use it for a certain purpose. And then based off of that purpose, then I draw the lines of whether or not how other people can use it. So let's say, Cameron, that you have a car and it's yours. you can think of that in terms of, you know, people shouldn't steal it, stab the tires, whatever. or you can think of it, which, you know, in terms of this is a vehicle that has been you know, this is a blessing that's been placed under my care, and I use it for.

feeding my family, helping my friends, traveling and doing ministry. And then it's very easy to make a defining line of if somebody wants to borrow your if somebody from your church wants to borrow your car to get to the airport, you're going to say, yes, that is in keeping with the vision that I have of this thing. And if somebody wants to, you know, slash the tower tires, you can say no to that because that's not in keeping with the vision that you have of this thing. And so we could play this out in all sorts of other ways. But yeah, let me designated stewardship.

What do you think of that as a phrase that gets us starting on thinking Christianly about ownership?

Cameron (07:58.135)

Designated stewardship. Yes, it has a good ring to it, Nathan. I'm thinking here a little bit about some of the hang ups that are kind of deeply embedded right now in these in these conversations, particularly with with people who are older, who saw the ravages of communist regimes, that sort of thing. Why how do we I guess this is before I give a a response, this is a a follow up question.

You have younger people though who are interested in questions about ownership and property and the stewards and stewardship there. How do we make these questions a little bit more comprehensible to some older people who do think that these have been settled once and for all? We've we've we've got conclusive evidence on this. Why is this even coming up? Because you said earlier, this is a good question. I think it is too, but you've seen those defensive responses to questions like this.

Nathan (08:57.815)

Mm-hmm.

Cameron (08:58.178)

I think as well. So let's talk a little bit about that 'cause I think it's a hang up sometimes.

Nathan (09:00.939)

Well o okay, so well so one of the things is is that designated stewardship does not necessitate legal ownership. So you you have the responsibility of designated stewardship even if you're renting. And especially if you're borrowing. So my my definition works in a in a broader context than a phrase like property rights would. yes, say say a little bit more of what you think the

The confusion is for the older

Cameron (09:33.286)

I think the the confusion, it seems to me, is that older people think the question of ownership and private property is not up for grabs. This has been well and truly settled because we've seen historically how other ideologies approach this and that it's extremely destructive. I think a lot of people have in mind, yeah, I mean just various forms of they think about the Soviet Union, for instance, that kind of thing. And so the notion that these these questions would

come up, I think some people are shocked by that. So it's trying to yeah, just make it yeah.

Nathan (10:07.923)

yeah. No, th th th this is this is this is a classical one in which your your views of property change v drastically depending on whether or not you have any. So so yes, i if you own a house, you're pretty locked into like the system being good. If you don't, I think you should still be locked into the system being good, but you're more susceptible to thinking, wait a second, there's an injustice here that I don't have, and therefore we need the government to somehow step in and equalize and

Cameron (10:36.857)

Hm, sure.

Nathan (10:37.461)

redistribute and balance the the ownership. And when you live in a very

yeah, you th there there there is a sense in which you can say me not having is a sign of me being a victim and the fact that somebody else has, that there is no possible way that you can come into property except through abuse of something. That is a dangerous way of thinking, but people are susceptible to it. if for a long time you're like, Okay, I've been working hard and this doesn't seem like it seem like it's unfolding, the system is rigged, the system is wrong. and forget about history. This is how I feel.

Cameron (11:12.955)

Now, what you're talking about with designated stewardship, I am one thing that is not coming to mind for me is possessiveness in what you're describing. You're giving an expansive vision of a more expansive vision, I would say, of property ownership that excludes that possessiveness. But that's something that's very, I think stereotypically seen to be American. This, you know, don't tread on me, get off my property kind of mindset. And it creeps into plenty of now.

Nathan (11:39.981)

Mm-hmm.

Cameron (11:43.284)

There are political dimensions to this as well, depending on what side of the aisle you stand on. But there there are certain types of people who even they would be professing believers, they would still have a view of property ownership that would sound a little bit more possessive, especially if, you know, if there was some catastrophe. We've talked about this a lot, Nathan. And there's somebody who's who's really let's just say preppers, okay? There's somebody who's a sort of prepper mindset, and it's never

I've got all these canned goods that I can share with people who are in need. So we need to talk about that a little bit too.

Nathan (12:19.819)

Yeah, so so the question does does come down to is whose is this and what are they asking of me as I care for it? And so if the earth is the Lord's, if you if you do or you do li or if you are living in a theological system, that that doesn't mean that you can't set boundaries. You can say, I think the way that I'm supposed to use this land is to put a fence around it and have cows in it, and that precludes my neighbors cutting holes through the fences and shooting all the animals in it. but it's it's not because I feel like I have an individual right grounded in some sort of

Cameron (12:25.892)

Mm-hmm.

Nathan (12:50.345)

concept of national law, which is great if it's there, but it's but I I'm saying, so how can we think about this if you don't live in a place that has a well-defined court system that legally records deeds and and boundaries? The other way to look at it is to say, no, I'm going to draw some lines here of what's s to be done here because I think this is the best way to use the land and to use the resource. So it's it's it'd be very hard for you, Cameron, to walk into

my backyard or any government agency to show up and immediately have a sense of the best way to care for what's going on behind my house. you kind of have to live there and know how the water flows when it rains hard and know where the sun comes up and which tree shade what places if you want it to really be productive and to bear good fruit. And so if we're looking at this as something that we steward in order that it would flourish and we have a vision of what we want to see happening there.

Cameron (13:40.645)

Mm-hmm.

Nathan (13:45.57)

Then that changes the way in which we set the boundaries of the do's and don'ts outside of rights language. So so I would say you have an obligation to steward well the possessions that have been entrusted to you rather than a legal right to defend them. And that's not to say that you don't have a legal right to defend them. It's to say that this is borrowings from Simone Weil here, that obligations precede rights. And so we have a a a bigger structure at play when we're thinking theologically here.

Cameron (13:58.652)

Mm-hmm.

Cameron (14:09.763)

Mm.

Cameron (14:13.401)

All right, but already your language is very unique here, Nathan. And so I'm gonna just isolate certain features. You're saying entrusted. So in some of these conversations, which I think is that's a humble phrase, entrusted to you. I can hear other conversations. Well, I can hear other conversations where people will say, entrusted, I earned this. I worked my way through, you know, countless different trials and and you know institutions.

Nathan (14:27.383)

Well yeah, I'm gonna be dead soon. I mean

Cameron (14:41.741)

I came up, I picked myself up by my bootstraps. This is America after all. Now, not everybody says this, but some people would say this is America after all. So it's a land of opportunity. If you just work really hard, you know, grit your teeth, and you apply yourself, you do it, you hustle, whatever, whatever phraseology you want to use, you can rise above your circumstances. And so those kind of people are often will use the no, this is I earned this. Forget your entitlement. I work. So how would you respond to?

to that as you yeah.

Nathan (15:11.987)

yes, because the work itself is a privilege, if you're thinking Christianly. So this goes back to, you know, it's a story I tell told a lot of times that one evening we were sitting down for dinner and we had our our prayer of Thanksgiving for the meal. And one of the kids was like, why are we thanking God for this? We grew everything on the table. And on one hand, it's that that's a it's it's an honest question and it's a good one from a four-year-old. But if you just step back and take that apart just even a little bit.

Cameron (15:30.053)

Mm-hmm.

Nathan (15:40.779)

you recognize the ridiculousness of the fact. There are a lot of people who are working really hard in this world. And I'll give you an example. So we're I was ever visiting our friend Jonathan Gerogi. And at the time that I was there, a dozen of eggs was like $1.94. And I was like, yeah, no, that's pretty comparable to prices at the time in an American restaurant. And then that you had all these guys lining up to do day day wage waiver labor wage day labor working in the field. So this is like using a hoe

For a five hour shift to dig into African heat. And that day's wage was $3. Okay? So if if if you're if the value of your time for five hours of physical callus building sweat is worth less than double a dozen of eggs, are you gonna say that that person's not working hard enough? So so I'm I'm just saying.

Cameron (16:13.915)

Mm-hmm.

Nathan (16:38.434)

The the ability to be in a system where your work can correspond to growth and development itself is fantastic. To live in a spot where you can put plants, seeds in the soil and the rain falls and you do a little weeding and nutrients that sustain your life pop up out of the ground is mind-boggling. So we have to zoom out here a little bit and say, even the ability to work, even to live in a context in which you do get compensated for your labor is a massive blessing in and of itself. And I I I think we don't want to.

Cameron (17:00.323)

Mm-hmm. Yeah.

Nathan (17:08.328)

separate our okay. I went to the office and I did this work and then I I came back and then I do this thing that is this this is my sacred space. No, actually your work is also. And so if designated stewardship is a reality, this isn't just about your possessions. It's about the way that you use your time and your effort. And so so back up and think about this like I often tell people who are teachers, nurses, all of those fields of like Jesus asked us to care for

The sick and injured. Period. Isn't it fantastic that you have a job that financially compensates you for doing something that Jesus asked us to do? Jesus asks us to teach people. Isn't it crazy that you get to have a job that financially compensates you for teaching people? So if we see our work as a form of service to other people under what it is that God is asking us to do as his disciples, then the work, even in and of itself, is a designated stewardship of your body and of your time.

And the fact that there are economic benefits from that are also something to be thankful for. So I don't know, does that at all get toward whi the heart of your question?

Cameron (18:14.533)

The Yes. Yes, I think so, because the attitude that you're outlining is the Christian attitude of if you do find yourself in a place of great abundance, you say, By God's grace, I have these good things. They are indeed entrusted to me by our Lord, and they are there for me. So you exercise dominion over them, but that dominion is for the benefit of God and neighbor.

And so that doesn't preclude setting boundaries. You do, right? You have to. You know, there are certain you lock your doors at night, whether it we're talking about your property, there, you know, there are rules that you've established for your property. But if your attitude is, this was a gift from God, and therefore I am to give to others, you use it for the service and the benefit of others. So that changes the language. That that attitude would change the language. You would if you're if that's your orientation, if that's your posture.

The likelihood of you saying things like, This is this is mine, I'm entitled to this, you know, I set the rules here, stay off my land and all that, that those wouldn't those kinds of statements wouldn't arise here if this if if this is the the fundamental posture.

Nathan (19:28.812)

Yeah. Well, so there are a couple other things that that go along with this. One is is that in in many of those parables, you do have this idea that those who have stewarded something small well will then be entrusted with more. And I so I think it's worth asking. Lots of times I've lived in my life thinking, Am I stewarding well what's right in front of me, what I have right now? And if I'm not, why would the Lord give me more or why would other people give me opportunity to store steward more if I'm not doing a good job of taking care of somebody else's something?

Cameron (19:44.698)

Mm-hmm.

Nathan (19:58.674)

and so that that that principle is at play. That's a that's a biblical concept that's that that is there also. so keep that in the back of your mind. I think if you're feeling a little stuck of saying, Am I, am I doing the best I can with what I have? And that's the way in which we honor the Lord. Now, here's another one that's been messing with me. first chronicles, I think this is 1522. This is the second time that David goes to move the ark. You remember the first time? Not so great. Enthusiastic worship in which somebody dies.

Cameron (20:11.995)

Mm-hmm.

Cameron (20:25.496)

no.

Nathan (20:28.743)

but in this one, they're moving the arc and it lists out the people who are involved in it, and it's talking about the guy who is in charge of the singing or the transportation, depending on the translation, is the the lifting up, I think is the literal read. And the NIV translates verse 22, interestingly, and it says, this was his responsibility because he was skilled at it.

Cameron (20:40.74)

Mm-hmm.

Nathan (20:51.735)

So think about the way this was his responsibility because he was skilled at it. And I and I got to it just makes you think like, if you are skilled at something and you're good at something, does that then mean that you have a responsibility and a moral obligation to do that thing?

Cameron (21:07.375)

Mm-hmm.

Nathan (21:10.823)

And and if you put that in the context then of the fact that biblically speaking, the vast majority, if not all, particular certainly it's 100% true for spiritual gifts, is that things are given to people in order to be a blessing to other people. I think we talked about this in a previous podcast that that none of the gifts are given for the benefit of the receiver of the gift. The gifts are given for the benefit of the people around the receiver of the gift. So the biblical concept of receiving

Cameron (21:31.791)

Mm-hmm.

Nathan (21:40.853)

Is for distribution, not for hoarding. But that doesn't mean that I'm that I'm not called to say, okay, and and this place is entrusted to me in my care. And then I do have a say on what goes on in this house, in these boundaries, in this organization, in this structure, because I built it for a reason and I have a vision for it. And then hopefully you're going to call up leadership who has the same vision or people who understand what you're trying to do. And then a a culture will be formed around that. but it is a

Cameron (22:08.464)

Mm.

Nathan (22:10.476)

It's a distribution network. It's not a bunker mentality when we think about our blessings.

Cameron (22:16.495)

All right. One one item that I I think we would be remiss if we didn't address it, and that's we need to can we put the book of acts into this conversation? Yeah, because yeah, so of course it comes up. It always comes up, you know, they yeah, they had all things in common. That's that's weird enough. But then, you know, everybody was giving and sharing everything as anyone had need. And so some people have yeah, obviously read this in in various

Nathan (22:25.572)

please do. Yeah. This came up.

Cameron (22:42.691)

ways and I find in certain circles this passage is treated as guilty until proven innocent. So let's talk a little bit about what's going on there. Yeah. Sure.

Nathan (22:49.046)

Yeah, can I let me throw out a couple. And and so between the two of us, I I probably inhabit the the the theology that is closer to having tried to live out some of this communal idealism a little better. So so the the things that I'm about to say come from within the context of those who have lived close to this and or tried. just a couple funny funny things that that pop up in my mind. I'm I'm ripping off my my grandpa written house here. one of those that he thinks is funny.

Cameron (23:01.785)

I would say yes, I'll grant you that for sure, yeah.

Nathan (23:18.474)

Is that you have the church in Jerusalem in Acts, everybody sells everything, nobody is in need, and then all the time that Paul spends later in the New Testament fundraising for the people in need in Jerusalem. It's a you're like, well, let's let's follow the story out. So his line is like it's like a honeymoon. but the thing about a honeymoon is when you get home, somebody has to go to work. And so there there was a a massive outpouring of the spirit. And when I I this just is like in the last two months thinking on this, this idea that they held everything in common.

Cameron (23:28.635)

Yeah, yeah. Yeah. Okay.

Cameron (23:37.659)

Mm-hmm.

Cameron (23:47.739)

Mm-hmm.

Nathan (23:48.064)

I think when we hold when we think of that sentence, we think they held that their possessions were in common, primarily, which is true. But actually what they had in common that preceded that was a common vision of who God was and an intense communal unity because of the clarity of the outpouring of the Holy Spirit. And so the thing that they had in common was an intense common identity. And then the material commonality flowed from the intensity of that common identity and community.

Cameron (24:01.353)

Yeah.

Nathan (24:18.146)

So, Cameron, if you and I were neighbors and we had the exact same vision for the world and for human lives, it would be very easy for us to share all of our resources. Most of the time when people are using that passage in a guilt trip way or something, they're starting with, if we held our, if we held our possessions in common, then we would have intense community. That is not what's being said there. You start with a common identity and then the can then the things in common flow from that.

Cameron (24:22.814)

Mm-hmm.

Nathan (24:48.492)

And so that's true in your household. You have you have a household vision of how things should be. And then when your kid comes up to you and says, Hey dad, can I borrow the tape dispenser? You say yes. Like, I mean, so because of the of the unity of the community and the intensity of the identity that comes from that, then the material equity flows downstream from that. So I would just say when you're reading the Acts passage, let's start with the priority of what they had in common as a religious experience and commitment.

Cameron (24:59.55)

Mm-hmm.

Cameron (25:10.527)

Mm-hmm.

Nathan (25:17.74)

And then see that the material commonality flowed from that, you can't force it back the other way and reengineer it in the other direction. So just two thoughts off the top of my head there.

Cameron (25:28.98)

That's well said. And I think if if our identity in in Christ structures everything else we'll do we're doing, we will we truly will have all things in common. Because I I find it important to I was talking about this not too long ago at a at a local church, because I said on the one hand, yeah, the all things in common, you can pro point to the selling everything they own, the property passages.

You can you can look at that and think it's a massively tall order. But then also in the book of Acts, not only do you have them, you know, Paul, you know, raising support, but you also have you have serious disagreements taking place in Acts as well. So even in the midst of they have all things they have all essential things in common, Paul still has serious disagreements with Barnabas over bringing

Nathan (26:23.55)

and whether the Greek or the Jewish widows get served first and

Cameron (26:26.535)

Yep. That necessitates an entire council. I I love those details in there because, like your grandpa is pointing out, they show us that this is not an idealistic book. This is still showing us actual people working out their problems together. So it's just I find that that's also something to bear in mind. When we think about at toward the end of his ministry, it's been a while since I mentioned Dallas Willard, so now I need to beep. Yeah.

Nathan (26:49.978)

yeah, please.

Cameron (26:51.881)

Toward the end of his ministry, Dallas Willard was suffering from cancer, so he was physically frail. And the question came up about the thousands of Protestant denominations, just basically division. And he says: to the extent that we all make following Jesus a priority, that is, make him our master, to the extent that we take his command seriously and all that, all those.

Nathan (27:03.15)

Mm-hmm.

Cameron (27:19.941)

inessential differences really do fall away. And all I can say is now in the view from my 40s, having seen a lot of collaborative efforts over the years, particularly when I lived in Europe, because in Europe, you know, Christians are vastly outnumbered. So you work together with your Orthodox and Catholic brothers and sisters in Christ, I can s I can say now that that is in my experience true. He's right. And what Nathan was saying there earlier about

Your identity in Jesus structuring everything else. Everything else is downstream from that, as you said, Nathan. That really is deeply practically true. And so that's just a good watch word for us as we have these conversations about whether it's about ownership, property, and you know, our human rights and all of that. Whether you're somebody who's older and you find these questions a little bit

Nathan (27:56.131)

Mm-hmm.

Cameron (28:16.913)

Threatening, or perhaps you're you're you're a little bit unsettled by the fact that younger people are asking them, or whether you're a younger person and you're just you're you're dipping your toe into this and you're trying to think seriously about all of the ethical considerations involved with property manag, you know, property ownership or all of that. It's important to remember that if to the to the extent that we are defined by Jesus, a lot of this

We'll be able to operate with a great deal more wisdom. And that I think that's just a very sound sound way of going about this of I was gonna say principle. It's not even a pr that's more of a vision. If we if we find that vision, it can help guide us in some of these difficult conversations. But of course there's more more that could be said here.

Nathan (28:48.03)

Yeah.

Mm-hmm.

Nathan (29:03.224)

Yeah. Let let me say two two things before you wrap this up for us. One is, so the so the the question we've been dancing around is is the description in Acts of the early church is that descriptive or prescriptive? Is it describing a time that was happening or is it prescribing a way in which we ought to act? And I'm going to say prescriptive, but in a different way than most people mean. Most people think prescriptive, therefore share all your possessions. I think it's prescriptive in the desire to be unified and to and to have

a a common view of who God is and a common intensity in worship in that way. So I think the the outpouring of the spirit does unite and bind in deep ways that then as a byproduct. So the prescription is in the worship, not in the material. And the description is in the material which flows from the commonality. Does that make sense? So because I think people say, is it prescriptive or descriptive? And my default is to say it's descriptive.

Cameron (29:53.202)

Hmm. Does it?

Nathan (29:59.669)

And some communitarian groups are going to say it's prescriptive, but I want to say actually no, it's it's prescriptive, but in a different category. It's in the theological structure of the of experience of the knowledge of the resurrected Christ by the power of the Holy Spirit. That's that's where we start and then it goes from there. Something something else to be said is that if the earth is the Lord's, then he does care how it's used. And whether or not this is a biblical principle, it is for sure just a a historically repeated observation.

Cameron (30:14.238)

Good.

Nathan (30:27.842)

that things flourish and are better taken care of when it's clear who's in charge of them. And so you you get into this thing, you know when you take a CPR training and it's like the you go, Annie, Annie, are you okay? And then it's like you call 911, right? You're supposed to designate the person who's supposed to call 911 because the danger is, is that if you don't, everybody will assume that everybody else is taking care of it and nobody does it. And so you designate who's supposed to call 911 so that it gets done.

Cameron (30:57.108)

Mm-hmm.

Nathan (30:57.366)

And I thought of this recently looking at a community garden that was largely a mess. And I thought the problem here is that nobody specifically is in charge of this. And it's an unproductive space because of that. and so this is this is not to say how do I maximize everything for my benefit, but if it is the Lord's, then he is going to put people who are uniquely gifted, skilled, and equipped in strategic places to be the designated steward of institutions, of congregations, of

physical plots of land of apartment buildings and all sorts of other things because they're going to see to it that the right thing happens. And so that is one of the problems with the broader sociological or or socialism or communist regimes is how in the world does a government or office 150 miles from here have any clue on the about the best way to grow crops or the best way to plant trees or the best way to build roads or the best way to, you know, build a bridge over this ravine. No, it takes people who are actually there, dependent on it, focused on that location.

Cameron (31:29.706)

Yeah.

Cameron (31:37.577)

Right.

Cameron (31:54.334)

Yeah.

Nathan (31:56.974)

who are in touch with the actual cause and effect of the way that the world works, not a distant ideology, but a actual practical somebody who cares and feels a responsibility toward that space, who's going to see it really turn into the beauty and the productivity that was intended for it. So now I'm not necessarily arguing just biblically other than to say if it is the Lord's and he cares about the outcome of it, then designated stewardship, which most people were going to call ownership, but I'm just wanting to have a bit of a bigger

Cameron (32:12.67)

Mm-hmm.

Nathan (32:25.976)

theological vision around it really is the best way for our neighbor, for us, for the planet, and whatever else there is out there is for us to to adopt this posture.

Cameron (32:38.962)

Very good. Hey, you're awesome. Not you, Nathan. You. Yeah, you, dear listener and dear viewer. Thanks for tuning in to Thinking Out Loud. And guess what? You want to be more awesome? Yeah, you do. Tell other people about it. Like, share, and subscribe. Shout it from the rooftops. You need thinking out loud in your life and in your week and in your ears. Yeah, you do. So, like, share and subscribe. And also,

Nathan (32:43.052)

Yeah, I know. This is fine.

Cameron (33:08.296)

If you'd like to support us financially, you can do that by going to www.toltogether.com.

Nathan (33:17.816)

That was a great first attempt at gaslighting Cameron.

Next
Next

Should Christians Engage or Separate From The World? | Fear, Politics, and Isolation