Nathan (00:00)
Hello and welcome to Thinking Out Loud. I'm your co host Nathan Rittenhouse.
Cameron (00:04)
And I'm your co host, Cameron McAllister.
Nathan (00:07)
And today I have a update, mild correction. That's not the right word. A developing thought on something. years ago, Cameron, you and I had done a podcast uh on talking about the Amish and sort of why they get a a pass in the culture wars. So when you looked at I
Cameron (00:23)
Mm.
Nathan (00:23)
forget what was going on in the nation at the time and everybody was up in arms about all the Christians, this and that, and I'm like, yeah, but everybody is still like the the Amish still have a good brand. They still have good marketing. Um you you don't really
care about their definition of or their views on marriage you like they're pies. You know, and that that was kind of the the direction that was going. And and the conclusion of that was is that I think there's a subconscious presupposition that the Amish are not a political threat. That they're by by separating and withdrawing themselves, they, yeah, we're okay with people who go off and kind of do their own thing. But as soon as you start sort of imposing your quirks onto the broader culture, that's where the um the walls get erected in the
uh people dig in and and the foxholes are dug and people start fighting. So um that was the nature of that. I then ran into an article um that that that is a different flavor of this and this has to do with measles. So in the
Cameron (01:18)
Mm.
Nathan (01:18)
state of New York, um well in the United States measles had been declared eradicated and now you have uh a comeback and and certainly this is not just an Amish thing. There are a number of different places in the country that there's a an influx wave of measles.
And due to the increase of that, and particularly in the state of New York, Amish schools had been exempt from measles vaccinations on a uh religious objection. And we'll get into that in a minute. Um, so that had been trucking along. Then as the measles outbreak continued in some of these places, that exemption was taken away so that you are looking at fines of up to $2,000 per student that wasn't vaccinated, even though they were in a private school.
Amish school that wasn't receiving any state or federal funding. Um, and I think at the time that I read it, the schools that that were under this, uh, it was a hundred and sixty-eight kids representing twenty some families, um, which comes out to like six kids per family at this school. So, you know, two
Cameron (02:20)
Yeah. uh
Nathan (02:22)
thousand bucks a pop, you're looking at, you know, an Amish family needing to pay twelve thousand dollar fine, I guess, per year. I don't know, um, for the fact that their kids weren't vaccinated. So the question is how far will this thing
um go. And then what's weird is then then there's a lawsuit filed on behalf of the Amish, I guess, for a religious exemption clause. Um and the Amish are like, we like living in New York, but we'll leave if we need to. Um and that's 20 some thousand farming families or something. So it's this whole big blah skyscl anyway. Um it's it's interesting to me on a number of uh angles. So one I want to talk to you about is what actually counts as a religious exemption.
And the second one is, can you really be separate as a Christian? Is this an actual workable thing? And so just as in the previous episode that we did where we said the Amish aren't perceived as a threat, politically speaking, let's f flip the script here. And the one thing that does scare people now is epidemiology. And so now if you have a a highly recognizable group of people who are associated with a preventable disease.
I think the
Cameron (03:32)
Mm-hmm.
Nathan (03:33)
the Amish brand could turn pretty quickly, uh, and people can say, Hey, you know what? I can do without the pies, because I don't want measles. So and and that's uh too tight of a false equivalence there, but I'm just saying that even if you don't have a political impact on the surrounding communities, if it's seen that you have a um a pathogen or a um something health related.
Cameron (03:55)
Mm-hmm.
Nathan (03:57)
That could be that could be the one yeah, so so anyway, I'm saying that I was wrong when I was like, Hey, the Amish kinda get a pass. No, this is one category where I think the state or the neighborhood could be like, Hmm, we're not as excited about you being here as we once were.
Cameron (04:09)
Well, maybe we qualify your remark. The Amish tend to get a pass so long as they don't do anything to interfere with public life.
Nathan (04:17)
There you go. Yeah.
Cameron (04:19)
Because I mean, in when it comes to just overt, you know, partisan politics, they aren't going to be a threat. But if we think about if we conceive of politics in the broader sense of the common life of the people, you know, seeking, you know, to live together and and to cooperate, then any serious faith, any serious faith is going to occasionally bring you into tension with that surrounding culture. It has to.
Because your your convictions are going to collide with public policy, inevitably. And how we negotiate those battles is going to be a key aspect of what it means to live in a religiously diverse country. And yeah, here the Amish are doing nothing unusual at all. They're simply following their their convictions. This just happens to be a matter that intersects with with the public life of the community.
And so yes, they don't get a free pass here. Yeah, it is kind of an interesting situation.
Nathan (05:18)
Well well there there's another thing that's interesting about
the there's another thing about that's interesting about the Amish that we don't talk about is that everybody is interested in whether or not immigrants assimilate into American culture. Uh here's a good example of a group that has not assimilated into American culture, doesn't speak English as their first language, um, and for a couple hundred years has not a and and also I think it's different, like if you live beside them or you're
touring. So like if you're touring, it's it's cute to get there. It's quaint to be stuck behind a horse and buggy. If you live there, you're like, oh for crying out loud. This is interfering with public life. Um so th there there
Cameron (05:58)
Yes, but
Nathan (05:59)
are a number of differ of different nuances there.
Cameron (06:03)
Well, you're no, you're bringing us into some interesting offensive categories that we do need to bring in here not to be sensationalistic, but not the outworkings, the public outworkings of all belief systems are not all the same. And some of them are more harmful than others. So we need
Nathan (06:21)
Mm.
Cameron (06:21)
to be honest about that. Getting stuck behind yes, uh a horse and buggy is a nuisance, especially if you live in the place. But having
Some community that is set up in a in a foreign country building its own place with its own set of laws with aspirations for some of those laws to supersede the laws of the land. I'm speaking in very careful terms here, but we can we can
Nathan (06:50)
Whatever could you be talking about, Cameron?
Cameron (06:52)
whatever could I be talking about, what's happening in many European cities right now, especially in in places like London or places like France.
This is not to single out just Islam, but it is to say that there are there are many there are one way of looking at Islam if you just examine the this you know, its sacred script its scriptures and its sacred texts, like the hadiths, is this is this is one outworking of that this is this is a theocratic religion. It's looking
Nathan (07:19)
Mm-hmm. Well
Cameron (07:21)
for a universal caliphate. Now there are millions of people who nuance that differently. But if you look at if you just
Look at the sacred texts and that so there are many, many people who have that aspiration. That is very, very different from being stuck behind an Amish person. Yeah.
Nathan (07:38)
Okay. Y yeah,
th well, there's another key difference here too is that the Amish by and large, as far as I know, don't accept any taxpayer like their schools aren't like they're all they are sort of economically like your taxes aren't going to s and
Cameron (07:54)
Independent. Mm-hmm.
Nathan (07:56)
so so it's like none of the Amish are on welfare, none of them are on Medicaid, Medicare, they're receiving no government support or um payments of of any kind. So
They're not on SNAP. They're not getting farm subsidies. They're I so the so in some ways you would say, well, this is a group kind of doing their thing, but I'm I'm not personally subsidizing their idiosyncrasies, and I can put up with those because they largely don't um even if they aren't the same as mine, they don't interfere with my concept of what it means to be an American. Could we say it that way, perhaps? That there is a a a different degree of separation when you take
Cameron (08:29)
Mm. Yes. We could. And
Nathan (08:32)
the finances out of it. Uh
Cameron (08:35)
And they're a highly peaceful group of people who don't I mean, you're uh you don't hear a whole lot of news stories about major major kind of tensions or problems with the Amish.
Nathan (08:46)
Oh, but every time but every time
there is one, you it definitely makes headlines. Like, remember like five years ago there was that guy running cocaine in a horse and buggy? Like, I mean that one's gonna I so so
Cameron (08:56)
Okay, I shouldn't be laughing at that. Yes, yes, that's right.
Nathan (08:58)
it's like it's the one group that out of hundreds of thousands of them, if one of them does do something, it it's gonna it's gonna make the news. So yeah, anyway.
Cameron (09:04)
Yeah. Of course it is, yes. Because but
but precisely because it's so out of character for this particular group, yeah.
Nathan (09:09)
Right. Yes. Good point.
Yeah. So yeah, th there's that. So I but here's here's the tricky thing of when when can you call a um so when does the religious objection argument not work? And and and this is dicey
Cameron (09:26)
Mm-hmm.
Nathan (09:26)
because it it's so baked into a feature of freedom of religion and the American experiment.
Cameron (09:32)
Well Nathan
Nathan (09:34)
But there are some other hard lulls and breaks where I would say
Yeah, I'm for uh religious freedom up until X. Like where how do you draw that line? Um, and then also what do you do if you also like I read the same Bible the Amish do and I'm vaccinated against measles. So who who who is the authority to say this is actually a legitimate conviction within the
Cameron (10:05)
Yes.
Nathan (10:05)
Amish framework?
And and where do they draw the lines on like what medical treatments to use and whatnot is varies across the different Amish communities. So that's tricky. But I'm just asking from the outside looking in here of like
Cameron (10:14)
Yes. Well
Nathan (10:17)
how how would you draw that line?
Cameron (10:20)
Well, I mean that would be it's exceedingly difficult to draw that line. And especially in a in a nation where w we do try to make the meaningful separation of church and state and here I don't I mean, one might say that all right, no, you are free to abstain. You're also free to pay the hefty state fine.
that's imposed for abstaining. So if if you want to follow so one one I'm s I'm certain this is probably well yeah, one response would just be, All right, yeah. No, you you're within your rights to do that. You have to then pay the fine. That's how that that's how
Nathan (11:00)
Mm-hmm.
Cameron (11:00)
this works. And then you you may practice your religion as you see fit.
But I can see others, of course, railing against this and saying, no, this would be this is a gross ri violation of one's, you know, freedom of religion. But of course, then, as you've pointed out, Nathan, this is something this is a this is a major public health concern. And it other people are deeply affected. So I will be curious to watch and see how if the Amish Amish are often very creative in their response to conflict. So I'm wondering what a possible creative
Nathan (11:34)
Mm-hmm.
Cameron (11:34)
response to this might be.
s the maybe involves alternate forms of schooling for a time or I I don't I don't know. Maybe they they build around certain different homeschooling methods.
Nathan (11:46)
I mean they pretty much are the all they
they they pretty much have the the market corner on alternate f alternate forms of schooling. Um
Cameron (11:52)
Yeah, they do.
Nathan (11:53)
the so yeah so so but that that also brings us into the second part of the conversation of is there actually such a thing as living separate? I mean and there's a biblical man come out from among them and be separate. You know, the Amish are gonna look at that that
Cameron (12:07)
Mm. Sure.
Nathan (12:08)
verse for sure. obviously they'd be in the world but not of the world and and that whole um that that
I I read that metric not to be um Jesus praise to the Father. I don't ask that you would take them out of the world. Uh so there's there's a sense in
Cameron (12:22)
Yes.
Nathan (12:22)
which geographically we have to be in proximity to humanity and the people as is created. That doesn't mean we have to adopt the world's operating system.
Cameron (12:30)
Mm-hmm.
Nathan (12:31)
Um so there's that. But
Cameron (12:36)
A lot of people we've talked about this before, Nathan. I'm curious. A lot of people romanticize the Amish. And I'm not just talking about the the romance novels, the Harleckan style sort of Amish romance novels, but
Nathan (12:46)
Yeah.
Cameron (12:48)
I mean romanticize them in the sense that they see them as a beautiful alternative to the machine in the modern way of life. Do you think that this
might mess with that vision a little bit for some people and might bring them a little closer to reality of saying, okay, now there are certain certain elements of this that perhaps are not fitting with that idealistic picture I had of of the Amish.
Nathan (13:13)
Yeah, I think the the trouble with this is that the the insight that you get into the Amish that's negative comes from the ex Amish who left because they had a negative so so it's it's
Cameron (13:25)
Mm-hmm.
Nathan (13:26)
very hard to get a um it's very hard to have a conversation with somebody in the Amish community who's like, Yeah, here's some of my frustrations and the ways in which things aren't going so hot these days. Like you're not going to have that conversation. So you either get the it'd be like trying to study evangelicalism by only talking to those who have YouTube channels about
Cameron (13:42)
Exvangelicals.
Nathan (13:43)
deconstructing.
Cameron (13:43)
Yeah.
Nathan (13:45)
Um, so I I th I think the sources do skew things a little bit in that direction. But yeah, are there perfectly happy Amish people? You bet. Um, and are there perfectly miserable Amish people? Yeah, you bet. 'cause they're people. So uh no, we we tend we tend to assume that a agricultural connection to the earth based life
is simpler and it takes a highly complex series of relationships and knowledge skill set in order to do that. So
Cameron (14:22)
Yeah.
Nathan (14:22)
it looks easy driving by at 50 miles an hour, but uh yeah there's a lot going on there. And now d d does it so let's let's think about um okay so how did the price of diesel affect the the Amish? How does the increase in healthcare affect the Amish? How does the you know you can look at a whole number of
um systems of in which you feel financially connected to uh that don't apply. And so my kids were asking me the other day, like, so what are the so how do how are the Amish able to live that lifestyle on what looks like a low income? And I said, well let's just start listing what their actual expenses are.
Cameron (15:01)
Mm-hmm.
Nathan (15:03)
Um so so I think there I think there is a a romantiz like yeah there's a way in which you could look at it and say, wouldn't that be lovely?
not to have an electric bill. Um, but how many people also want to chop enough firewood to heat their house and cook their food and have enough acreage to pasture a horse? And how many people want to hitch up a horse to be able to travel 15 miles an hour wherever you're going or ride your bike or whatever? Um, so e everything is a cost-benefit analysis. And do you remember Sam Alberry in his book Um The Seven Myths of Singleness said something wise where he said,
That one of the things that single people do is you take your worst day being single and you compare it to your imagined best day being married. You never take your best day being single and compare it to your
Cameron (15:53)
Mm-hmm.
Nathan (15:53)
imagined worst day being married. And so I think you take your worst day not being Amish and compare it to your vision of the best day of being Amish. You never take your best day with the life that you have and compare it to the worst day of being Amish. And so, so I think.
Usually when people are looking across the fence and saying that way of life is better, um you're you're comparing a c a a current misery that you have with a perceived benefit. Um, but you don't ever wake up feeling great and think, Man, I wish I was a miserable Amish person milking cows at 4 30 this morning. So there's that.
Cameron (16:29)
yeah, there is that.
Back to the the religious freedom question. You know, that it is getting expanded in interesting new ways because we live in an interesting new moment. Did you see that at the University of Kentucky, there was a gentleman there who got a he basically he is allowed to he's exempt from AI usage, which has been highly it's
Nathan (16:51)
no.
Cameron (16:52)
been very it's been pushed very hard among university staff and
He got a religious exemption to it, defining himself as a humanist.
Nathan (17:03)
Oh, interesting.
Cameron (17:04)
And
it was granted. So yeah, now I know this threatens to derail the conversation on the Amish. I'm just bringing it up to to say that religious exemption and religious freedom is being is obliged to go in some in interesting directions because of just where we're at. It in and all of it many of these changes involve technology, whether whether vaccines and vaccination mandates or
AI usage, mandated AI usage in an office space. And so, yeah, this gentleman just said, No, I'm a I'm a humanist. I value the human process of thought and forming my own eth ethical conclusions. I feel this violates my ability to act as a as a moral agent. I mean all all the langu very, very legal language. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Nathan (17:47)
Okay, okay, okay, time out. Time time out. Timeout. So
so so this is my question about can you actually be a separatist?
Cameron (17:54)
huh.
Nathan (17:54)
There's no way that guy isn't using AI. Whether it's controlling the traffic light that he's driving through or he's
Cameron (18:02)
Right.
Nathan (18:02)
um the the the security cameras outside the university or the automatic lights, like you
Cameron (18:08)
Mm-hmm. Sure.
Nathan (18:09)
you can't. And in the same way, so the Amish can say we have
A religious uh objection to the measles vaccination because we feel like our trust is in God and this is impinging upon a category in which we expect God to take care of us. Well, yeah, but you also work in US dollars. Like, are you trust why don't you just trust God to take care of your fiat currency? Like you you have to and they drive their horses
Cameron (18:33)
Yeah, you can
Nathan (18:34)
and buggies on the right side of the road. Like there there isn't a way that you can yeah.
Cameron (18:38)
Be completely separate. Yeah.
No, that's right. That's the that's the basic tension with a lot of this. And I do often think of Jesus' words that you quoted earlier. Yeah, you know, I send you out into the world, I do not take you out of the world. I take that very seriously. So being in and not of, or being salt and light, these are the biblical images and metaphors and turns of phrase that ought to give us our bearings here. But as soon as we've we we come across this territory.
from time to time on thinking out loud, when we talk about being implicated as a human, basically. Because when you look at this when you just look at the web of practices you are necessarily entangled in. And I mean you're not a disinterested observer. You know, from the clothes you're wearing to the food you're consuming to the laws of the land that you're to the police force and military that on which you are dependent.
you you're implicated and involved in ways that just defy the imagination. So you you can't be c yeah, to try to
Nathan (19:43)
Yeah. So
Cameron (19:45)
extricate yourself and be pure from all of that is impossible. Yeah.
Nathan (19:48)
So so I
know a guy who drives Amish construction workers. The Amish owns this as truck, but this guy isn't Amish. He drives the truck for them because they can't drive the truck. And they can use a cell phone, but they can't touch the cell phone. So he dials the numbers and holds the phone in the cab for them to talk into the phone to make the business arrangements. So so they're not touching the phone and they're not driving
Cameron (20:10)
See, you could say you could say this is yeah.
Nathan (20:13)
a truck, but they're talking on a phone and
that a guy is holding while sitting in the truck that they own but they never drive in order and so
Cameron (20:20)
Let's be honest
about what that is. That's called legalism. That's that that is what that is.
Nathan (20:24)
Okay.
But that's not yeah, I think that's a highly similar thing to the Kentucky guy saying, I'm a humanist and I don't want to use AI. It's
Cameron (20:33)
Mm-hmm.
Nathan (20:34)
it's right online. Let me let me give you a very, very complicated analogy here, Cameron, and you have to roll your eyes and go with it. But um there are a number of places in my life that I see an apple tree that is growing along a fence row and the branches are reaching out over the fence into a pasture.
Um, so the the c and they're like cattle or sheep come up under the tree for the shade, they eat the dropping fruit, they nibble the branches off. Um, but the tree is on the other side of the fence. So the the trunk and the root struct well, three qu two thirds of the root structure are safe from the the impact of the animals. Another third is actually taking nutrients from the defecating animals there. So there's a little bit of a symbiotic, I'll trade you shade for nutrients thing going on. But the but there but there's a fence there.
And the roots are on one side and the fruit is dropped on the other side. And it and it seems to me that there is a Christian vision here of going out into all the world where I want to bear fruit in all of the categories in which I'm involved, but I do want to make sure that I have clarity on where my roots are on and
Cameron (21:42)
huh.
Nathan (21:42)
and and so and then so there needs to be a fence um for my continued flourishing and protection, but also for me to be able to continue to bear fruit. I can't.
Cameron (21:51)
Mm-hmm.
Nathan (21:52)
If if the tree is in the pasture, it gets eaten by the cows or the sheep eat the bark off of it or whatever. Um, but if it's on the other side of the fence, that's safe from them, but it is contributing by being separate. And so I think these questions of religious objection, if I can form them and and chalk a line and say, No, this objection is in order for me to continue bearing missional fruit, I'm sympathetic to that argument. If I say I'm drawing this objection because it's a
Form of me using the American political freedom to carve it's based out of fear and I'm carving out a pr a special protection for myself, then I think you've lost the Christian ethos in that. So I I know that's a super complicated analogy, but it's the best I could come up with on the spot of thinking about a way in which we have a boundary that our roots are being nourished in one place and we're bearing fruit in another while still having some distinction and separation from it's it's just it's not just a free for all.
And I do have to do things that um
t in order to preserve the fact that I will continue to exist. So like, um, our closest group of Amish here are all were all worried about technological advancements within the broader Amish and wanted to step it back a notch because they were getting towards some of that driving trucks and you using cell phones even they weren't touching them and running, you know, air filled tired equipment and they're like, Whoa, we're going to lose our way of life unless we draw some harsher lines and step back a notch. Um
So it it's a little bit it's a little bit weird for me to pick on the Amish on this because I think actually a lot of American Christians would do well to draw some more definitive lines for themselves. Um, but maybe this conversation helps us pick and push at in a reflective way, some of those ways in which we want to be wise about what it is we aren't we are or aren't participating in, but I
Cameron (23:48)
Mm-hmm.
Nathan (23:48)
think we don't want to do it in a way that looks like it's just a special pleading or protectionism. Um
And not something that actually is making a contribution in a in a broader sense.
Cameron (23:57)
I think it's a fascinating topic, especially as we think about whi the ways in which religious freedom is going to the directions it's gonna go in the years that that follow here, especially with all these technological advances. It's a strange moment. And thanks for sticking Yeah, Anne.
Nathan (24:13)
Yeah, well,
I was gonna say there there are a number of accommodations that are made for um I'm happy to live in a society that um I think Muslims have done a good job of maybe pushing for some boundaries on human decency in hospitals and the use of gowns and nudity and that sort of thing. Um also between like the Anabaptist and the um Muslims like with women's head coverings and like TSA.
And how do you go through TSA
Cameron (24:44)
Mm-hmm.
Nathan (24:44)
if you have your hair styled in a religious way? Um
Cameron (24:47)
Mm-hmm.
Nathan (24:48)
and so there are
most of our world does want to work with people who have and I think we often respect people who say, hey, here's an issue that I I want to engage in society, but here's a barrier to me I I by and large the American way is to accommodate that as far as it is possible. Um but even doing that is a fairly Christian idea. And so yeah, like you said
It'll be interesting to see where this goes.
Cameron (25:23)
Absolutely. And in case you missed it, you have been listening to Thinking Out Loud a podcast where we think out loud about current events and Christian hope. If you like what you hear, and I surely hope you do, I won't call you Shirley, I'll call myself Shirley. All right. Like, share, and subscribe. You I mean we hear I'm hearing some repeated murmurings about why don't you interact with the comments section? All
Nathan (25:45)
Yeah. Yeah, Cameron, if you're gonna promise these things.
Cameron (25:48)
right. Well, maybe I will. Maybe we will. You know and
Nathan (25:50)
Cannonball right
in there.
Cameron (25:51)
Yeah. No we now if we interact if
Nathan (25:53)
I have a religious
objection to commenting on YouTube videos, so I don't really, but
Cameron (25:56)
There we go. Rest my case.
No, so if if yeah, the the the the euphemism for all of this engagement. So we may we may engage from time to time. It'll it'll be here usually. I d I don't really see myself, you know, typing away furiously as a keyboard warrior on YouTube, but we will talk to you here. So we look forward to that. So keep subscribing. If you want to sub if you would like to support us financially, you can do that by going to www.toltogether.com.